A “ heavily drunk ” Miami-Dade Schools Police sergeant repeatedly punched, resisted and insulted two Doral Police officers, dropped their body cameras, fought with an officer in ground while handcuffed and provoked him to call for backup, according to video and police records.
But the sergeant. Dubraska Guevara, 33, was not arrested that evening. She is also not the subject of charges in the incident.
Instead, Doral officers debated the sergeant and let her go home.
None of these details were included in Doral’s police report on the incident.
Now the incident and Guevara’s conduct are being investigated by Miami-Dade Schools Police. But experts said it raises questions about whether the sergeant received preferential treatment from fellow law enforcement officers and whether, under similar circumstances, a citizen would not have received preferential treatment. been handcuffed and released without legal consequences.
Raises the issue of preferential treatment by Doral cops
“If it was someone like you or me, we would have bigger problems than what this officer was [in]”Said Suman Kakar, professor at Florida International University and police expert.” There is some bias ahead. The report does not even mention all the chaos it has caused there.
Doral Police spokesman Rey Valdes told the Miami Herald that the “majority of drunks” with whom his agency’s agents deal were not arrested. He said officers had the discretion to make an arrest.
“In this case, it was not a crime,” he said. “If anyone was hurt here, it was the officer in question and his reputation.
Valdes said he had not watched the entire video. He said the case was properly documented. He said officers C. Curbelo-Mesa and J. Valle, who handled the incident and decided to release the sergeant, are not under any kind of internal review.
“We don’t do special treatment,” Valdes said. “There are dozens of drunks we deal with on a daily basis out there that we don’t even document. We put them in a taxi and get them out of there. It’s not like we’re trying to sweep them under the rug.
The unrest begins at the Cityplace Doral restaurant
Doral Police were involved when they sent officers to investigate a report of a disturbance at Heaven Mykonos in CityPlace Doral. The director general said two white women – Guevara and school police officer Jennifer Grenier – were “messy and disruptive” and refused to pay their checks. He wanted them to go.
Doral’s police officers were a man (Valle) and a woman (Curbelo-Mesa).
The restaurant’s general manager cited in the report, Luis Toledo, declined to comment.
Hour-long videos recorded by the two officers’ body cameras showed a belligerent Guevara repeatedly punching them and slipping onto her school police colleague Grenier.
Guevara was handcuffed and placed in a Doral police vehicle until she was picked up by another school policeman and taken home. Officers also took the handguns issued by the Guevara and Grenier department inside the restaurant and emptied them, as the video shows.
Police led Guevara and Grenier through a stairwell, where body camera videos showed Guevara using “hand pistols”, as if he was simulating shooting a gun and cleaning the room. ‘a stairwell during a search of a building.
Once outside, Agent Curbelo-Mesa put Guevara’s hair in a ponytail.
Guevara is seen and heard on video making several inconsistent statements to officers, including, “Mum — uh, I need my mom — in drugs.” She became belligerent when she believed Grenier was recording her on her phone, although Grenier said she was making arrangements for a friend to pick them up.
Guevara is seen on video trying to take off her shirt as she was handcuffed by Valle. Throughout the body camera videos, Grenier cooperated with the police and repeatedly yelled at Guevara to calm down.
Video captured on Doral cops body camera
During the brawl, the video shows Guevara handcuffed to the ground shouting “BLM motherf — uh” and “Black lives matter!” An officer from Doral warned her to watch what she was saying because it was being recorded by their body cameras.
When she retrieves Guevara, she briefly raises her arms and punches Valle, a male officer, before they fight on the ground. She yelled at the officers to “take my legs” when the reinforcement officers arrived.
The incident report written by Doral officers does not mention that Guevara had an altercation with them. Instead, he said there had been a “verbal altercation” between Guevara and Grenier.
“Ms. Guevara started a verbal altercation with Ms. Grenier and subsequently began removing clothing from her person,” the report says. “Due to her behavior, Ms. Guevara was handcuffed to prevent other actions. “
Police report revised later
The report was later revised to identify the two women as police officers from the Miami-Dade Schools Police, although the original incident report only listed Guevara’s address as the Schools Police Headquarters. .
Doral Police refused to make Constables Curbelo-Mesa and Valle available for interviews.
Raul Correa, a retired school police commander who is now a consultant with Miami Tactical, LLC, said without knowing any facts or details of what led to the incident, “this appears to be inappropriate behavior by the from the officer in question “.
“Law enforcement is a profession with the highest possible standards. Police work is difficult enough without these types of incidents, ”he wrote in an email. “In the current climate of police surveillance, these types of incidents unfortunately contribute to the public’s negative view of the police, which is unfair. “
FIU police expert Kakar said citizens would be afraid to lie about videotaped actions, and officers are held to higher standards for relaying such incidents for possible prosecution. .
“The report should have reflected what really happened, not what is desirable by law enforcement or the department,” Kakar said. “It should reflect the facts because that is the purpose of the law. This is why the public loses confidence in the police, in the law or in the courts.
Miami-Dade Schools Police Investigate
Miami-Dade Schools Police Chief Edwin Lopez released this statement on Friday:
“I know members of our agency were recently involved in an out-of-service incident in the town of Doral,” he said. “The incident is currently the subject of an administrative investigation by our internal affairs unit. As this is an open investigation, no further information is available at this time.
Grenier, 33, is not the subject of an internal investigation by the school police. A source familiar with the administrative investigation said Grenier never refused to pay a bill at the restaurant and no one asked anyone to leave the restaurant.
The source said Grenier was embarrassed by the incident and “deeply distraught” that other media described her as an accomplice in wrongdoing.
Fraternal Order of Police 133 President Al Palacio declined to comment. Reached by phone, Guevara declined to comment. She is now represented by a private lawyer.
Guevara has worked for the school police since 2014. Grenier has been in the force for less than two years.
The Miami-Dade state attorney’s office, informed of the school police’s internal review, did not act on the incident.